The 90-Day World Sprint Begins April 7th →

The Real Threat to Creatives Isn’t AI – It’s Their Identity

Let’s cut the bullshit about AI being the big bad wolf coming to blow down the house of creatives everywhere. The real danger isn’t some algorithm. It’s how tightly you’re hugging your process like it’s your personality.

Here’s the thing. If you define yourself as “someone who spends eight hours perfecting brush strokes” rather than “someone who brings visual ideas to life,” you’ve got a problem. Because AI doesn’t give a damn about your process. It just cares about results.

“But AI Steals Our Work!”

I hear it every time I bring this up. “AI is trained on our work without permission! It’s theft! It’s going to replace us!”

Look, I get it. The training data issue is complex. But let’s be real – humans have always learned by studying what came before them. Every artist you admire built their style by absorbing the work of others and putting their own spin on it.

The Process Trap

I used to think being a writer meant suffering through drafts, staring at blank pages, and meticulously crafting every sentence until my fingers bled. That’s what writers do, right? We suffer for our art.

What a load of crap.

When I first tried AI writing tools, I felt weirdly guilty. Like I was cheating on my identity. The words came too easily. Where was the suffering? The struggle? The dramatic sighs as I deleted entire paragraphs?

Sound familiar?

If you’re nodding, you’ve fallen into the same trap I did. You’ve mistaken the hard parts of creation for the value of creation.

What Actually Matters

Nobody who reads your novel gives a shit if it took you five years or five weeks to write. They care if it moved them.

Nobody looking at your design cares if you hand-coded every element or used AI to generate the first draft. They care if it solves their problem.

Nobody watching your film cares if you storyboarded every frame by hand or used AI to visualize your concepts first. They care if it made them feel something.

Your audience cares about the destination, not how painful your journey was to get there.

The Real Creative Value

The value of a creative isn’t in the mechanical execution. It’s in:

  1. Knowing what to create in the first place
  2. Making judgment calls about what works and what doesn’t
  3. Understanding human emotions and how to trigger them
  4. Having taste and vision that transcends tools
  5. Bringing your unique lived experience to your work

AI can’t replace any of that. It can only replace the parts that were probably wastes of your time anyway.

And here’s the thing about that “stolen work” argument: AI doesn’t understand what it’s doing. It doesn’t know why your creative choices worked. It doesn’t have the life experience that informed those choices. It’s just recognizing patterns. You still have the most valuable thing: the ability to know why something works and what it means. The meaning behind creation is the part AI can’t touch.

The New Creative Identity

What if being a creative wasn’t about suffering through tedious processes but about bringing more ideas to life?

What if instead of making one perfect thing a month, you could make ten? Or a hundred?

What if you could focus on the parts of creation that actually light you up instead of the parts that drain you?

That’s the opportunity AI presents. But you’ll miss it completely if you’re too busy defending your identity as “someone who does things the hard way.”

The Choice

Every creative right now has a choice:

You can be the person who proudly says “I don’t use AI because I’m a REAL artist” while watching your relevance slowly fade like a Polaroid in the sun.

Or you can be the person who says “I use every tool available to bring more of my ideas into the world” and actually fucking thrive.

The same people who are screaming about AI theft today were probably the ones who thought digital cameras weren’t “real photography” or that electronic music wasn’t “real music.” And guess what? The world moved on without them while the adaptable ones found entirely new forms of creative expression.

The first is comforting. The second is powerful.

From Process to Purpose

Here’s a simple reframe that changed everything for me:

Stop identifying with how you create and start identifying with why you create.

If your identity is “I’m someone who helps people see the world differently through visual stories,” then AI is just another brush in your toolkit.

If your identity is “I’m someone who helps businesses connect with customers through clear messaging,” then AI is just another way to draft and refine ideas faster.

When you tie yourself to purpose instead of process, you become unbeatable.

The Real Question

So the question isn’t “Will AI replace creatives?”

The question is “Will creatives replace their outdated identities before it’s too late?”

Because the creative who learns to dance with AI rather than fight it isn’t just going to survive.

They’re going to create things we can’t even imagine yet.

And isn’t that what being creative is really about?

More Essays

Polymathy in the Age of Specialization: Building Bridges Across Knowledge Domains

Discover how mastering multiple disciplines creates cognitive flexibility, sparks innovation, and gives you the edge in an era of increasing specialization.

The Samurai’s Path: How Miyamoto Musashi’s Five Principles Can Transform a Broken Life

Discover how legendary samurai Miyamoto Musashi's five principles can help you transform devastation into strength and rebuild a shattered life.

Architects vs. Gardeners: Finding Your Creative Path in Business

Discover if you're an architect or gardener creator type, how it affects your business approach, and how AI tools can help you leverage your natural style.

The Real Threat to Creatives Isn’t AI – It’s Their Identity

Nobody who reads your novel gives a shit if it took you five years or five weeks to write. They care if it moved them. Your audience cares about the destination, not how painful your journey was to get there.

Beyond the Hustle

Why working harder is the wrong mindset to making more money.

Social Media Is Electricity

Do you need social media for your business to survive? Technically? No. But you don't want to live in the technically world.

The New Content Engine

Your online business is driven by content. But the old ways of building content engines only lead to burn out. Here is how to set yourself up for the future.

The Success Paradox: Why Your ‘Character Flaws’ Might Be Your Superpowers

Think a superiority complex is bad? New research shows it might be exactly what you need. Here's why the most successful people never apologize for being 'too much.'

The Beautiful Prison of Content Creation And How to Break Free

Tired of creating content that disappears? Learn how to build worlds instead of walls, create meaningful impact instead of meaningless impressions, and use AI to scale your truth instead of your noise.

The Enemy Effect: Building Worlds Through Opposition

The Enemy Effect isn't just another branding tactic - it's how you build a movement. Discover why the most powerful force in your brand isn't what you stand for, but what you stand against.